Step-by-Step Guide to Getting a Background Check on Employees

When you’re hiring new employees, how can you ensure the person joining your team is trustworthy and qualified? A background check. It’s an essential step in the hiring process — and one you absolutely can’t afford to skip. 

But where do you start? How do you build a seamless background-check process that’s both compliant with privacy laws and effective in finding any red flags? Whether you’re an experienced hiring manager or new to the game, you need a solid process to run these checks smoothly and professionally.

Why are background checks so critical in the recruitment process? A thorough background check helps you safeguard your business against potential risks, from outright misconduct to misrepresentation of qualifications. It can reveal a lot, including a candidate’s criminal record, employment history, education credentials, and even their driving record — depending on the role. 

It's a bit like flipping over a puzzle piece to see the full picture before you build. Beyond protecting your team and company, it’s also about ensuring fairness. A transparent process reflects a professional, responsible hiring policy that builds trust with both candidates and employees. 

Step 1: Define Your Internal Process and Policies 

The first and most crucial step? Establishing a clear internal policy for background checks. This ensures consistency and fairness across all candidates. 

Here’s what you’ll need to address when defining your process:

• What type of checks will you conduct? Will you focus on criminal background, education verification, or employment history? Choose depending on the role.
• Which roles require checks? Some positions, like those handling sensitive data or finances, may demand more thorough screening than others. 
• What are the compliance laws in your region? Background checks are regulated, so familiarize yourself with legal requirements like those outlined in the fair credit reporting act (FCRA) in the U.S. 

Be sure to document your policies. Not only does this demonstrate you’re running a professional recruitment process, but it also keeps you accountable during audits or disputes. 

Step 2: Inform Candidates During Recruitment 

Transparency is key. To avoid surprises, introduce the background check requirement early. Make it clear during recruitment that all candidates will undergo checks if they move forward. 

Here’s how to communicate this step effectively:

• Include it in the job description: Mention you’ll conduct background checks in the role’s official posting. 
• Discuss it during interviews: Be upfront about why and when background checks are conducted. 
• Obtain consent: Candidates must consent to the check before they proceed. Always provide them with a consent form to sign, outlining what’s being checked. 

This builds trust and ensures no one feels blindsided after accepting an offer. 

Step 3: Partner with a Reputable Background Check Provider 

Next, you'll need a trusted partner to help handle the actual screenings. Manual background checks are time-consuming and often prone to human error — professional services streamline the process and ensure thorough results. 

Here are some factors to keep in mind when choosing a provider:

• Accuracy: Look for a service known for precise and reliable reports. 
• Scope: Make sure they offer the type of checks you require, such as verifying social security numbers, employment, or criminal records. 
• Compliance: Reputable providers will be fully compliant with privacy laws like FCRA or GDPR guidelines. 

A reputable provider like Checkr, SipringVerify or HireRight will typically offer an easy-to-use platform where you can monitor the status of your background checks in real time. 

Step 4: Tailor Your Checks to the Role 

Not every position needs the same level of scrutiny. Hiring a cashier? A criminal record check might suffice. Looking for a financial analyst? You may want to dig deeper into education credentials and past employment. 

Matching the intensity of the background check to the role helps you save time and costs while ensuring you’re thorough where it truly matters. 

Here are some examples:

• Customer-facing roles: Focus on criminal record and customer service history. 
• Tech positions: Check educational background and previous project work. 
• Corporate leadership: Conduct in-depth checks on employment and credit to assess fiscal responsibility. 

Customize your process to be both efficient and relevant. 

Step 5: Analyze Results and Follow Up 

Once the background check reports come in, it’s time to review them carefully. Look for any discrepancies between the candidate’s resume and the information uncovered. 

Be mindful of potential red flags, but use common sense. Not every issue in a report automatically disqualifies a candidate. For example:

• Minor gaps or inconsistencies in employment can often be explained. 
• Outdated offenses may no longer reflect the person’s current character or work ethic. 

When something raises a concern, reach out to the candidate for clarification. Often, their perspective can provide helpful context that isn’t reflected in the report. 

Step 6: Finalize the Hiring Decision 

After you’ve completed the background checks and addressed any issues or questions, you’re ready to make a final hiring decision. 

Here’s the ideal process for this step:

• If the background check is clear, proceed with your onboarding as usual. 
• If the check raises concerns, communicate your reasoning with the candidate. They should have an opportunity to respond or review the report if they wish to contest the findings. (This is legally required under the FCRA in many cases). 

Your goal should always be to remain fair, consistent, and transparent — this reflects well on your company’s reputation and makes for a better experience for all involved. 

Background checks are one of your most powerful tools for making confident hiring decisions. They protect your company, your team, and your future hires, while ensuring a safe and reliable workplace for everyone. By defining your internal processes, being transparent with candidates, partnering with the right services, and tailoring checks to specific roles, you can streamline this critical step and create a hiring process that’s as effective as it is fair.

Subscribe to weekly updates

You’ll also receive some of our best posts today